2026-03-31(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 1-1 Mount Pleasant Academy
2026-01-29(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 1-0 Arnett Gardens
2026-01-23(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 0-1 Mount Pleasant Academy
2025-04-18(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 0-2 Mount Pleasant Academy
2025-01-19(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 2-0 Arnett Gardens
2024-10-17(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 1-1 Mount Pleasant Academy
2024-08-27(CONCACAF Caribbean Club Championship)
Arnett Gardens 1-2 Mount Pleasant Academy
2024-03-24(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 2-0 Arnett Gardens
2023-12-28(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 2-0 Mount Pleasant Academy
2023-06-04(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 1-3 Mount Pleasant Academy
2023-05-30(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 2-2 Arnett Gardens
2023-04-09(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 0-0 Arnett Gardens
2023-01-10(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 3-2 Mount Pleasant Academy
2022-05-30(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 0-1 Mount Pleasant Academy
2022-03-13(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 1-1 Arnett Gardens
2021-07-25(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 1-0 Arnett Gardens
2020-02-24(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 0-2 Mount Pleasant Academy
2019-12-03(Premier League)
Arnett Gardens 1-0 Mount Pleasant Academy
2019-09-29(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 2-2 Arnett Gardens
2019-03-17(Premier League)
Mount Pleasant Academy 1-0 Arnett Gardens