2026-03-08(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 0-0 Chicago Fire
2025-09-28(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 2-0 Columbus Crew
2025-02-23(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 4-2 Chicago Fire
2024-05-19(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 1-3 Columbus Crew
2024-03-10(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 2-1 Chicago Fire
2023-09-20(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 3-0 Chicago Fire
2023-06-11(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 1-2 Columbus Crew
2022-09-03(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 0-0 Chicago Fire
2022-07-10(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 2-3 Columbus Crew
2021-11-07(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 2-0 Chicago Fire
2021-08-15(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 1-0 Columbus Crew
2021-06-19(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 2-0 Chicago Fire
2020-09-12(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 2-2 Columbus Crew
2020-08-20(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 3-0 Chicago Fire
2019-08-31(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 1-1 Chicago Fire
2019-07-18(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 2-2 Columbus Crew
2018-08-23(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 1-1 Columbus Crew
2018-06-06(US Open Cup)
Columbus Crew 3-3 Chicago Fire
2018-05-12(Major League Soccer)
Columbus Crew 3-0 Chicago Fire
2018-04-08(Major League Soccer)
Chicago Fire 1-0 Columbus Crew